Murder Mystery Letters by Mail

There's something uniquely thrilling about a good murder mystery! The suspense, the clues, the satisfaction of piecing together the truth. Now imagine that mystery arriving in your mailbox as a series of weekly personalized letters, each one pulling you deeper into the investigation. Welcome to the world of murder mystery letters by mail.

What is Fiction Mail?

Fiction Mail brings storytelling into the physical world by delivering personalized fiction directly to your mailbox. Each series arrives as handwritten-style weekly letters from fictional characters, with your name woven naturally throughout the narrative. Using a custom handwriting font and premium colorful envelopes, every letter feels like correspondence from a real friend sharing their incredible, and often dangerous, story with you.

Whether you prefer weekly excitement or monthly adventures, Fiction Mail offers various series from 4-letter weekly series to monthly series lasting a full year! And, we have some amazing murder mystery series that will get you excited to check your mailbox!

Murder Mystery Series to Try

Seeking Justice Series

Promotional Graphic for Fiction Mail Seeking Justice Series of Stories as Letters

When Jen's neighbor is found dead, the police quickly rule that he took his own life. But Jen isn't convinced. Through eight weekly letters spanning two months, you'll join her amateur detective journey as she investigates what she believes is murder. Each 5-6 page letter on Jen's personal stationery brings unexpected twists, suspicious characters, and startling revelations. This is classic whodunit storytelling at its best, perfect for anyone who loves piecing together clues and second-guessing their theories. See the Seeking Justice Series of Fiction Mail.

Buried Secrets Series

Promotional Graphic for Fiction Mail Buried Secrets Series of Stories as Letters

Katie and her husband Matt were excited about renovating their vintage house, until construction crews unearthed a skeleton in the basement. When Katie discovers the remains belong to a woman who once lived in her home, she embarks on a quest to solve a 30-year-old murder. But her investigation attracts the attention of a wealthy, powerful family determined to keep their secrets buried at any cost. This action-packed four-week series hits close to home, literally, as Katie's letters bring you along on her dangerous search for truth. See the Buried Secrets Series of Fiction Mail.

Beach House Murder Series

Promotional Graphic for Fiction Mail Beach House Murder Series of Stories as Letters

What starts as a month-long escape to a beach house takes a dark turn when one of Chris's housemates is found murdered. With the police investigation stalling and the killer potentially still among them, Chris launches his own covert investigation. Is the murderer one of his fellow housemates? Through four weekly letters, Chris recounts his search for the truth while living under the same roof as potential suspects. See the Beach House Murder Series of Fiction Mail.

Why Choose Fiction Mail's Murder Mystery Letters?

There's something special about receiving a physical letter. It makes the story feel real in a way digital content never quite captures. When you open your mailbox to find a letter from Jen updating you on her investigation or Katie warning you about the dangerous family she's uncovered, the line between fiction and reality blurs in the most delightful way.

These murder mystery series make excellent gifts for mystery lovers, book club members, or anyone who misses the excitement of finding something other than bills in their mailbox. With free shipping and the option to include a custom gift message, you can surprise someone special with weeks or months of suspenseful storytelling.

Ready to start your murder mystery adventure? Choose your series and prepare to become part of the investigation, one letter at a time.

Back to blog